The presence of an LGBTQ+ student body at a private Jewish university in New York is causing controversy. In late August, Yeshiva University (YU), which enrolls more than 5,000 students, filed an urgent appeal with the country’s Supreme Court to resolve a dispute against a group of students. organizes educational and inclusive reception events. The establishment, which is part of the Modern Orthodox movement, refuses to allow the association to meet on campus.
In his appeal to Yeshiva University, the country’s highest judicial body, he presents himself as one “A deeply religious Jewish university», claimed to know the union “violates his sincere religious beliefs in order to educate his undergraduate students in Torah values”. The institution is founded on respect for the freedom of religion guaranteed by the first amendment of the American Constitution. The appeal follows a New York state court ruling in June that allowed the union to be officially recognized on campus.
The appeal was denied
The Supreme Court, in its response on Wednesday, September 14, refused to hear the case, referring to the lower courts. “The motion is denied because it appears that the plaintiffs have at least two more avenues to seek summary or interim relief in state court.” the judges said.
a decision interpreted as “victory” On behalf of the LGBTQ+ association camp, Katie Rosenfeld, a lawyer for the youth group, said that they can continue their activities until the next legal decision. Therefore, the university is obliged to recognize the union at least for the 2022-2023 academic year.
Suspension of student clubs
In response, the administration of Yeshiva University decided to suspend all undergraduate clubs and comply with the requirements. “The US Supreme Court’s Roadmap for Protecting Religious Freedom” Organization according to email sent to students.
The ban represents another twist in the years-long legal dispute surrounding the admission of LGBTQ+ students at the university. Already in 2020, seven student activists filed discrimination complaints with the New York Commission on Human Rights.
At the heart of the controversy is the uncertain status of the university, founded in 1897. yeshiva, Talmudic school for the study and training of future rabbis. The institution, which has since become a private university, now presents itself as a university on its website “A multidisciplinary institute that combines the knowledge of Western civilization and the rich treasures of Jewish culture” and hosts diplomas in so-called subjects “profane”.
Officially, the institution does not have the status of a religious organization and must comply with New York State law, which prohibits discrimination on a number of grounds, including identity and sexual orientation.
If the case were eventually heard by the Supreme Court, the ruling could prove the establishment right: Since the arrival of conservative Justice Amy Coney Barrett on the Supreme Court in 2020, religious liberties cases have almost always upheld the faith. based institutions.